This post contains affiliate links
About a year ago, I began reading Lysa Terkeurst’s book The Best Yes. I wasn’t too familiar with Lysa so I did some research and was disappointed to learn that her church permits her to have authority teaching over men, which I don’t believe to be in line with 1 Timothy 2:12 (please note, however, that women are called to teach women who are younger in the faith as commanded in Titus 2:3). My discouragement grew as I realized that her church also used her book rather than the Bible for teaching during regular church services.
With the release of Lysa’s latest book, Uninvited: Living Loved When You Feel Less Than, Left Out, and Lonely, I was curious to see how she would encourage readers to handle rejection Biblically.
Uninvited begins with Lysa telling the story of how she personally experienced rejection from her father as a child and how it impacted her as she became an adult. Uninvited is largely autobiographical with a bit of Bible sprinkled in.
Uninvited does contain some truths presented in its pages including, “He (Jesus) was betrayed, mocked, abandoned, beaten, crucified, and buried. . . His crucifixion on the cross became the defeat of death. His broken body became the resurrection hope for the world,” (pg. 175).
However, the bulk of this book leaves much to be desired when it comes to understanding how to handle rejection the way Jesus did and would. The tone of the book is saturated with feel-good, self-help advice. Uninvited seems to encourage Christian women to pull themselves up by their bootstraps rather than fix their eyes on Jesus (Hebrews 12:1-4) who Isaiah 53:3 tells us, “. . . was despised and rejected by men, a man of sorrows and acquainted with grief; and as one from whom men hide their faces. . .”
An additional concern I have with Uninvited is that Lysa claims to receive direct revelation from God – “And that’s when a very clear sentence popped into my head. You aren’t set aside, Lysa. You are set apart. It wasn’t audible. And it wasn’t my own thought. I knew it was a thought assigned by God that I needed to ponder” (pg. 102). Although it is Biblically true that God’s people are set apart, in the sense that He has redeemed them for Himself, Lysa’s verbiage is troubling because it makes it seem as though God spoke to her outside of the Bible. Claiming to receive direct revelation from God is a problem that is all too common in Christian literature today, especially that which is aimed at women. Her statement made me think of multiple passages of Scripture that warn against adding to what God has said in His Word (Deuteronomy 4:2, Deuteronomy 12:32, Proverbs 30:6, Revelation 22:18). Although I don’t believe Lysa did that, I do believe it is very important to be careful with such wording.
Peter was a disciple of Christ and His close friend, the one upon whom He would build His church. Although Peter physically heard God, he still urged believers to consider Scripture more trustworthy than his experience. This same thinking should be applied anytime someone claims to receive any sort of revelation from God apart from Scripture.
These are some of the issues I had with Uninvited and therefore I do not recommend it.
I received Uninvited compliments of BookLook Bloggers in exchange for my honest review.
Thank you so much for reviewing this book! Unfortunately, I didn’t think to look at reviews before buying it. Could you suggest a better book that is along the topic of rejection? I struggle greatly with past rejection and had high hopes for this book.
Hi Amanda, thank you for reading my review and for commenting! I don’t typically recommend resources I haven’t read but I believe Shame Interrupted: How God Lifts the Pain of Worthlessness and Rejection by Ed Welch would be a good choice. Ed is a certified Biblical counselor and you can read some of his blog posts on the topic of shame/rejection here. I also recommend this blog post from Desiring God and this post from Revive Our Hearts. I’m praying that your heart will be comforted by God and that these resources will be of true help to you!
Excellent review, Lauren (and thanks so much for the link up and quote :0) The point you brought out about using multiple translations and paraphrases is an important one. I’ve seen many teachers and preachers do this because they’ve chosen a certain word, phrase, or idea for their sermon or book and they “translation shop” until they find a Bible version that uses that same word, phrase, or idea rather than simply using the most reliable translation throughout their teaching. This is a form of eisegesis, an unbiblical way of teaching God’s word.
Michelle, I’ve enjoyed reading your blog and I’m humbled that you not only read my review but have been kind enough to leave a comment! It is so hard to find theologically solid books, especially for women. Like you, I believe it is so important to thoroughly examine what is out there and warn my sisters. I completely agree about your thoughts on eisegesis. As a woman, I am tired of being asked what God’s Word means to me – I long to know what it says about HIM! I desperately need to be pointed to the good news of Jesus and the cross because my own heart is quick to forget who Christ is and what He has done for me. Thank you for being faithful to keep the truth of Christ as the foundation for all you do!
Thank you for your review – I now have three of Lysa’s books and to be honest, have not been as attentive as I should to what she’s teaching. I appreciate your thoughts, and after reading your review and other articles warning about her teaching, I have to admit I have a dilemma. A dear friend who I’m working through “Having a Mary Heart in a Martha World” has given me this book and wants to study it next. I would rather do something more Scriptural (just in the first chapter of Uninvited I noticed a serious absence of Scripture), but I don’t want to hurt my friend’s feelings. She belongs to a Word of Faith church, also, and I haven’t yet found a good way or time to approach this error. Anyway, any suggestions? Thank you for your time!
Hi Linda, thank you for your comment and for reading my review, I’m glad it was helpful to you. Your situation with your friend is a tough spot to be in. I have been in similar situations with with Christian women I know and love and navigating through them wasn’t easy. As believers we are called to speak the truth in love as described in Ephesians 4:15-16 and it seems as though you have the perfect opportunity to live this out with your friend. I would pray and ask the Lord for wisdom before speaking with her. When you do speak with her I would encourage you to make your concerns known by humbly showing her how Scripture is at odds with the books she enjoys reading and teachers she enjoys listening to. These conversations are difficult and in my experience the key for me has been humility and having a heart of unity. I encourage you to be gracious as your friend simply may not know that the resources she relies on are not grounded in Biblical truth – for many years I was unable to discern truth and I am still in the process of learning how to do so. Ultimately the heart of relationships amongst believers is to sharpen one another (Proverbs 27:17) into Christlikeness and if our words are harsh, they stir up anger (Proverbs 15:1) rather than give grace to all who hear (Ephesians 4:29). A gentle answer, indeed, turns away wrath and it seems the most appropriate approach considering we are called to live peaceably with all as far as it depends on us (Romans 12:18). Know that regardless of your friends response, you are showing the ultimate form of love for her by telling her truths that are essential to the health of her soul. She may not appreciate what you have to say but ultimately we are called to obey God rather than man (Acts 5:29) and we can take heart knowing that God is pleased by our obedience and our eternity has already been secured by Jesus. I’m praying that your conversation with your friend will be profitable and for her heart to be soft toward the truths of Scripture. I’m praying also that the Lord will keep you from fearing man as I often do and will give you the boldness to speak the truth in love. Thanks again for reading and commenting, I really appreciate it! In Christ, Lauren
Hi, Linda! If you’re still looking for a different book to study with your friend, you might want to give “Attitudes of a Transformed Heart” by Martha Peace a try. That book is chockful of Scripture, so it sounds more up the alley you’re wanting. 🙂 Praying that you’ll be able to have those hard conversations with your friend and that she’ll receive it well.
Sitting in a full room of women arrived for first day of Uninvited.
I had never heard of Lysa.
THANK YOU for objective review.
I’ll be grateful to be the voice of truth.
Thanks for heads up.
Hi Lauren,
I searched for reviews of Uninvited, which I’m still reading, and found your blog.
Would you explain 1 Timothy 2:12? For instance, a famous, beloved Christian woman who has spent most of her life in a wheelchair spoke at the weekend services at my church about the meaning of suffering from a biblical perspective. Men were present. Was that teaching permissible, impermissible, a gray area?
Thank you. : )
Hi Kirstin,
Thank you so much for taking the time to read my review and leave a comment. In 1 Timothy 2:12, Paul is giving Timothy instruction on how the church should function when the members are gathered together for regular worship. Since a Sunday service is regular worship at most churches, it would seem that having a woman preach during that time violates the instruction set forth in Scripture.
This doesn’t necessarily mean that women can never speak/teach in the church but there are Biblically appropriate contexts for when and how this should occur. We see in Titus 2 that older women are called to instruct younger women. This is a discipleship relationship that can occur in many ways but I have typically seen it played out through Bible studies, small groups and naturally occurring friendships within the church. I have been blessed to have many women in my church, who are older in the faith, take me under their wing in a sense, and show me what it looks like to imitate them as they imitate Christ in the various roles that they occupy (i.e. Believer, wife, mom, friend, ministry leader, employee). This wasn’t necessarily a formal time of study but it has benefitted me greatly to learn from older, Godly women.
We also see in Scripture that women can hold the position of deacon, as Phoebe was a deaconess (Romans 16:1). The English word for deacon comes from the Greek word diakonon which means servant. Thus the role of a deacon is a non-teaching role and Biblically, it is permissible for a woman to serve the church in ways that don’t require her to hold teaching authority over men.
It sounds like the woman you may be referring to is Joni Eareckson Tada, who I know has been interviewed during regular teaching times and has also shared on suffering Biblically at various conferences. I had the privilege of listening to the recording of her session from John MacArthur’s Strange Fire conference and was greatly encouraged by her love for Jesus. In these cases, she isn’t teaching over men, and as far as I know doesn’t have a regular teaching ministry where she is in authority over men so it seems to be a gray area that should always be approached with wisdom.
Paul’s warning applies to regular teaching ministry in the church and his caution is especially applicable today with the rise of female pastors. The way Lysa Terkeurst’s church functions in allowing her to have regular teaching authority over men is unbiblical not only in violation of 1 Timothy 2:12 but also in that their authority during regular service times is her book and not Scripture.
Thanks again for your comment, it challenged me to dig a bit deeper to see what the Bible has to say about this issue. Feel free to reach out should you have further questions. I am not an expert by any means, but I do enjoy studying the Bible and hope that through this blog I can encourage women to do the same.
In Christ,
Lauren
I appreciate your eloquent response. I was writing about Joni, and if it seemed that I was questioning her actions, I didn’t want to use her name and have this pop up in Internet searches. (Not that I understand how that works . . .)
I share your pet peeve about using multiple translations. The Purpose Driven Life always comes to mind as the worst example.
What a tremendous relief it was to find this post. After years of leading worship at “Women’s Retreats” which seem to be more of a cheerleader session for self worth, I was beyond discouraged to find out that this years retreat for our church was based on this book. After prayer, study, a little “why me” self pity, and bringing it up to the pastor and his wife, the retreat planning is on hold until the pastor can review this book for himself. I would love to ask for prayers for wisdom for our pastor (and myself) as he discerns the truth about this book and hopefully points the planning team in a solid scriptural direction.
I would love to live nearby and go out to coffee and talk theology and not be discouraged and feeling like a fanatic for wanting scriptural truth. Period end of story truth. It is so easy to feel isolated when it seems the truth is being so pushed in the rear as desire for acceptance, being “better”, cleaner, more presentable, and feeling happy with oneself take precedence. I am glad to read that other women are also striving for this truth. Sola scriptura, sister 🙂
Melody, thank you for reading my review and taking the time to leave a comment! I am so encouraged by what you wrote and it is sweet to see the Lord using this little blog in ways bigger than I could have imagined. I will absolutely be praying for your pastor to have wisdom as he leads and for him to rightly handle the word of truth (2 Timothy 2:15). I will be praying for you too as you have the opportunity to speak the truth in love (Ephesians 4:15), which is often easier said than done. I recently attended a Biblical counseling seminar hosted by my church in which the speaker was Dr. John Streett and he emphasized the importance of pastors reading books for Christian women because the number of unreliable options is rapidly increasing. Also, this past week, one of the ladies discipling me told me that it’s not always about what the authors say, but rather what they are not saying – I found this to be true with Uninvited, especially with the lack of Scripture and total lack of the Gospel. I think the biggest thing I’ve learned by reading books that aren’t very solid is that women desperately need to know God’s Word. It is my hope that this blog can be used to encourage women to grow in their knowledge of the Bible and to study it for themselves. Too often, I find that we are quick to rely on resources with “Christian” labels to help us grow Spiritually and forsake prioritizing the sufficiency of Scripture above all else. Thanks again for reading and commenting and please know that I am praying for you and your pastor as you navigate what would best help the women in your church grow in their love of our dear Savior.